About Us

VOTED BEST PIZZA IN THE HUDSON VALLEY FOR 2017!!!

Pizza Mia is a gourmet Italian pizzeria that offers delicious traditional New York-Style pizza, homemade Italian cuisine and unparalleled service not found in just any other pizza establishment. Pizza Mia provides a new pizza experience by offering a variety of new products such as our original Grandma Pizza, coupled with an elevated level of quality in existing products. Our commitment to quality is evidenced through our use of the absolute finest ingredients available. The pizza is made using only 100% all natural mozzarella, the handmade, hand-tossed dough is prepared from scratch daily, and our extensive sauce line is made with the freshest ingredients & by customer request is bottled for your convenience. Through our variety and quality of offerings, combined with our superior customer service, Pizza Mia’s goal is to ensure that each of its customers has the best pizza experience imaginable. In addition to its great tasting pizza, Pizza Mia offers its customers a large selection of gourmet quality sandwiches, wraps, pastas, dinners, & desserts. The menu items are created by trained chefs that utilize the best old-world Italian recipes continuing a family tradition that the Mazzellas have been upholding at Casa Mia Restaurant in Highland, New York for over 37 years! Given the superior quality of its offerings, Pizza Mia intends to not only provide the best pizza experience available to local residents, but to also be the caterer of choice at local businesses. Pizza Mia's catering menu has the breadth, scope, and a delicious selection which make it attractive for every occasion.

Composed from the great teams found in both Casa Mia Restaurant, which opened in 1973, and at Rino’s Pizza in New Paltz, NY, Pizza Mia first opened its doors in the Bridgeview Plaza in Highland back in early 2005.  Based on its success and strong customer demand the company expanded to New Windsor, NY.  We are now embarking on our 3rd LOCATION in the TARGET PLAZA on RT 17K in NEWBURGH! 

Pizza Mia & Rino’s Pizza were voted the Best Pizza in the Hudson Valley, by Hudson Valley Magazine in 2006 & 2008 and our team continues to marvel our customers in all of our locations!  We are pleased to also say that Pizza Mia was AGAIN VOTED BEST PIZZA IN THE HUDSON VALLEY IN 2013 by Hudson Valley Magazine! We were also VOTED BEST PIZZA IN THE HUDSON VALLEY 2015, 2016 AND AGAIN IN 2017 by the listeners of one of the area's most popular radio stations, 101.5 WPDH!!! Stop by to encounter why Pizza Mia has been aptly labeled as "Love at 1st Slice!".

  • Highland Pizza Mia: (845) 691-4545 
  • New Windsor Pizza Mia (845) 563-9100
  • Newburgh Pizza Mia (845) 561-1400
Please Contact Us to Fax You a Copy of Our Daily Specials for Great Deals on Our Sandwiches, Wraps, & Pizzas! We also offer daily homemade soups, gourmet slices of the day & a different LUNCHBOX SPECIAL everyday!!  Give us a call at the store for more details! 

About Us

Photo Gallery

Now With 3 Locations!

VOTED BEST PIZZA IN THE HUDSON VALLEY AGAIN IN 2017! Come & Discover Why Pizza Mia has been  described as LOVE AT 1ST SLICE!!

Highland, NY (Bridgeview Plaza) 

New Windsor, NY (Rt. 32)

Newburgh, NY(Target Plaza 17K)